Self-help message board
How to contact us
Web links directory
Tips and advice
Help Me, I'm new!
Fair pricing petition
Magix Video Deluxe Plus
How to get started with
computer video editing
Join our ongoing campaign
DV Ken Morse Edition
stills for the screen can give fantastic effects but has traditionally
required expensive rostrum camera equipment or software. Can a UK-based
software house really have come up with a decent pocket-money alternative?
cameras to zoom into and around photographs, maps and other documents
can produce some great video footage, but the kit can be expensive and
hard to use. Compositing and editing programs such as Adobe After Effects
and Sony Vegas can simulate rostrum cameras, but can be tricky to use
Last year's launch of a program dedicated to the job, Canopus Imaginate,
was welcome. It wasn't hugely expensive and had a comfortable interface
and fairly intuitive operation. However, for some editors, even Imaginate's
£175 price-tag was too much to shell out for a program they might
only use now and again - though for some projects, of course, still-image
animation can be of fundamental importance to the story.
Enter east-London-based Lumidium with DigiRostrum DV - a £50,
DV-only version of the company's broadcast-standard rostrum technology.
The DV version is one of three branded with the name of veteran broadcast
technology guru Ken Morse. The others - DigiRostrum Pro (£450)
and DigiRostrum HD (£750) - offer added functionality for broadcast-standard
projects, including unlimited image file size and QuickTime support.
QT support aside, for camcorder projects, there doesn't appear to be
much missing from the DV version.
There are differences in approach between DigiRostrum DV and Canopus's
offering, though be aware that a MkII version of Imaginate, priced at
£140 (inc VAT) and with an upgraded features set, is due in the
next few weeks.
DigiRostrum can output the two main types of DV (I and II), while Imaginate
1's DV output is Canopus's own flavour of DV Type II. Both programs
can also output using any AVI Codec available on the host system.
DigiRostrum can import 10 types of still image file - BMP, Gif, JPG,
PCD, PCT, PNG, RGB (Silicon Graphics), Ras (Sun Raster), Targa and Tif
(though not LZW-compressed Tif). That's one more than Imaginate - the
Canopus program can't handle the more advanced Silicon Graphics and
Sun Raster formats, though it does support MNG, an animated variant
of the PNG image format made up of successive frames of an animation.
Unfortunately, though, Imaginate 1 loaded only the first frame of the
MNG animations we threw at it. The two more expensive versions of DigiRostrum
can bring in AVI video clips as source files, but this isn't possible
with the DV version or with Imaginate.
Other features offered in Pro and HD versions include Motion Blur; 32-bit
and alpha channel output; hundreds of keyframes; QuickTime support;
unlimited image-file size; and Super Sampling - which is said to prevent
image-flicker and shimmer that can be seen in areas of fine detail and
high contrast when zooming out a long way. In addition, the HD version
offers unlimited output frame size for High Definition projects.
DigiRostrum DV is a competent tool with professional-level features,
though the lack of QuickTime support seems a little mean, even given
the program's £50 ticket. We'd also like support for alpha channels,
but maybe that's asking a lot at this price-point. A few niggles need
ironing out, but a decent manual and a little bit of work under the
hood is all that's required.
The program offers better and more intuitive control than Canopus's
Imaginate 1, and also outstrips it in functionality in other areas.
That's amazing given that DigiRostrum is so much cheaper and produced
by a small independent UK outfit, rather than a big international company.
The same comparison may hold true with the forthcoming Imaginate 2,
but we've not had the chance to test that yet. One area where Imaginate
wins out is in its ability to be used as a plug-in from within popular
video editing programs such as Adobe Premiere and Canopus Edius. If
Lumidium could crack that nut, DigiRostrum would be well on its way
to being a mainstream contender.
DigiRostrum DV can be recommended to anyone wanting to produce decent
image-pan DV footage - that includes pros as well as those on a tight
budget. And, if Lumidium sorts out those niggles, the program should
have a bright future. Download the free trial version and see for yourself.
Read the full review
in July 2004's Computer Video magazine.
Reviewed in this issue:
Roxio Easy Media Creator 7
DigiRostrum DV Ken Morse Edition
Training for Adobe After Effects 6
Giant Magic Bullet Movie Looks
In July's news:
DVD Architect and Vegas go pro
Premiere Pro upgrades
Updated Adobe Video Collection
Apple authoring MkIII
Canopus Imaginate: Part II
Smarter After Effects
Bringing Dolby Digital 5.1 home
Sony shrinks DVD camcorders
Graphics cards get interesting - and faster, too
£999 Tiny Athlon 64 laptop